How do I know if my marketing and BD is actually working?
Most professional service firms are doing some form of marketing and business development. Content is being published. Events are being run. Meetings are taking place. Budgets are being spent.
But here’s the uncomfortable question many firms avoid asking:
Is any of it actually working?
If you’re struggling to link activity to results, or you’re reporting on vanity metrics that don’t reflect reality, you’re not alone. Many firms find themselves in this position, where there’s lots of activity happening, but it can be difficult to understand whether it’s moving the needle for the business.
In this blog, I’ll explore what “working” really means, what to measure, and how to connect marketing and BD efforts to outcomes that matter for your firm’s growth and success.
The problem with vanity metrics
Marketing teams are often under pressure to “show something”, which leads to reports full of data points that feel impressive, but mean very little when it comes to understanding the real impact on your business.
Think about metrics like:
- Website traffic numbers
- Email open rates
- Social media impressions
- Event attendance figures
These numbers might look positive in a monthly report, but they don’t tell you whether you’re building trust with the right people, generating quality leads, or moving conversations closer to instructions. They’re what we call “vanity metrics” because they make us feel good but don’t necessarily correlate with business success.
The truth is, these metrics can sometimes be misleading. You might have great website traffic, but if those visitors aren’t your ideal clients or they’re not taking any action, then that traffic isn’t particularly valuable to your business.
What should we be measuring instead?
To know if your marketing and BD is working, you need to track progress against commercial outcomes. That means understanding what marketing is there to do and how BD supports those goals.
Here’s what you should be considering:
1. Is visibility leading to action?
Marketing should increase awareness and interest among your target audience. But the key question is whether those touchpoints are resulting in meaningful engagement that moves prospects towards becoming clients.
Track these metrics:
- Marketing-generated leads and enquiries
- Website actions such as contact form submissions or resource downloads
- Email replies or direct engagement on LinkedIn
- Referrals that can be traced back to specific content or campaigns
- Phone calls or meeting requests that mention your content
Think about setting up proper tracking systems so you can see the journey from initial awareness through to enquiry. This might involve updating your website analytics, implementing lead tracking in your CRM, or simply asking new enquiries how they heard about you.
2. Is BD activity moving prospects forward?
It’s not enough to attend events or meet contacts. You need a clear plan to progress those relationships and turn networking into new business opportunities.
Track these metrics:
- Number of qualified conversations (not just any conversation)
- Meetings scheduled with new or dormant contacts
- Pipeline movement and progression through different stages
- Time from first contact to instruction
- Quality of opportunities being generated
Consider implementing a simple scoring system for prospects based on their likelihood to instruct and potential value. This will help you focus your BD efforts on the relationships most likely to generate results.
3. Are marketing and BD working together?
Many firms measure marketing and BD separately, but the real value comes when both functions support the same goals and work in harmony.
Track these collaborative metrics:
- Campaigns that lead directly to BD meetings
- BD feedback that informs future content creation
- Win rates for proposals that have been supported by marketing materials
- Internal collaboration between marketing and BD teams
- Cross-referencing of marketing touchpoints with BD success
This integrated approach means your marketing team understands what resonates in BD conversations, whilst your BD team can leverage marketing materials and insights to have more effective conversations with prospects.
4. Are we generating the right type of work?
Sometimes marketing brings in leads, but not the kind your firm actually wants or can profitably serve. This is often a sign that your messaging or targeting needs refinement.
Track these quality metrics:
- Lead quality based on sector, company size, and budget
- How well prospects fit your ideal client profile
- Repeat work and client retention rates
- Cross-selling success across different services
- Profitability of marketing-generated clients
It’s worth regularly reviewing the quality of leads coming through different channels. You might find that certain marketing activities are generating lots of enquiries, but they’re not from the types of clients you want to work with.
5. Is our activity supporting strategic growth?
Ultimately, your marketing and BD should support the firm’s wider strategic goals, whether that’s positioning in specific sectors, improving brand perception, or driving revenue growth in particular areas.
Track these strategic metrics:
- Performance in priority sectors or geographical regions
- Brand recognition and perception (through surveys or client feedback)
- Direct contribution to revenue or profit growth
- Alignment with partner-level business development plans
- Market share growth in target areas
This requires you to be clear about what your strategic goals actually are, and then ensure your marketing and BD activities are designed to support those goals rather than just generating any activity.
How do I bring all this together?
The key to effective measurement is starting with clarity about what you’re trying to achieve. This means asking yourself:
- What are we trying to achieve with our marketing and BD efforts?
- How do we define success for our firm?
- What do we need to measure to track progress towards those goals?
- Who is responsible for tracking and reporting on these metrics?
This process might involve tightening up your CRM system, reviewing your reporting processes, or aligning your teams more closely around shared goals. It might also mean having honest conversations about whether your current activities are actually contributing to your business objectives.
Practical steps to get started:
- Audit your current metrics – List everything you’re currently measuring and ask whether each metric directly relates to a business outcome
- Define your ideal client – Be specific about who you want to work with so you can assess lead quality
- Map your client journey – Understand the typical path from first contact to instruction
- Implement proper tracking – Ensure you can trace leads back to their original source
- Schedule regular reviews – Monthly or quarterly reviews to assess what’s working and what isn’t
Making it work in practice
The most important thing is to start somewhere, even if your tracking isn’t perfect initially. You can always refine your approach as you learn what works for your firm.
Consider setting up a simple dashboard that tracks your key metrics in one place. This doesn’t need to be complicated or expensive. Even a well-maintained spreadsheet can be effective if it’s regularly updated and reviewed.
When firms understand what’s working and what isn’t, they can make better decisions about where to invest their time and resources. They can stop doing activities that aren’t delivering results and double down on the approaches that are generating real business outcomes.
Final thoughts
If your reports are full of activity but light on outcomes, it might be time to take a step back and reassess your approach.
Marketing and BD shouldn’t be about staying busy or hitting arbitrary targets. They should be about making genuine progress towards your business goals and generating sustainable growth for your firm.
The good news is that once you start measuring the right things, you’ll have much clearer insights into what’s working and what needs to change. This will help you make more informed decisions and ultimately achieve better results from your marketing and business development efforts.
Need help?
If you would like help with your marketing, bringing on a marketing consultant with a fresh pair of eyes can make all the difference. I work with B2B businesses and professional service firms in London, Kent, the UK, and Europe, specialising as a legal marketing consultant. Please get in touch or book a free 30-minute consultation.
Related Services
